Home › Counties › Orange › 5243 W LAKE BUTLER RD

5243 W LAKE BUTLER RD

Windermere, Florida 34786 · Orange County · Parcel 132327839200180

$1 056 668
Assessed Value
$1 258 390
Market Value
—
Annual Tax
$1 031 668
Taxable Value
Ownership
OwnerBRUMBAUGH CINDY L
Mailing Address5243 W LAKE BUTLER RD WINDERMERE FLORIDA 34786
Property Details
Year Built1996
Living Area2 715 sq ft
Lot Size24 194 sq ft
Use Code001
Valuation Breakdown
Land Value$800 000
Just (Market) Value$1 258 390
Assessed Value$1 056 668
Exemptions-$50 722
Taxable Value$1 031 668
Sale History
DatePriceBuyerDeed
1 de octubre de 2025 $2 700 000 — 05

Comparable Properties Nearby

2012 MCKINNON RD, Windermere
Parcel 012327000000015
Assessed: $812 284
12202 MCKINNON RD, Windermere
Parcel 012327000000021
Assessed: $810 677
12104 MCKINNON RD, Windermere
Parcel 012327000000023
Assessed: $834 019
12128 MCKINNON RD, Windermere
Parcel 012327000000026
Assessed: $972 509
12010 MCKINNON RD, Windermere
Parcel 012327000000037
Assessed: $1 204 620
12236 MCKINNON RD, Windermere
Parcel 012327000000060
Assessed: $842 188
Could you be overpaying property taxes?

If your assessed value is higher than market value, you may qualify for a tax reduction. Florida homeowners successfully appeal assessments every year.

Check if you qualify →